What is a REAL dialogue?
A real dialogue is what happens when a Realised person meets with someone who WANTS to 'get it'. We can call the Realised person the Guru (if we want to - it is just a word) and the one who wants to get it can be called a disciple. The danger in doing this is that it can create all kinds of concepts about what the Guru should be and the disciple should be, which are more barriers to overcome.
However, the essential ingredient is this: The Guru must be realized - in the sense that he must not be speaking from theory or books or concepts alone. Otherwise it is the blind leading the blind.
The disciple must be SINCERE in that he does not just want to debate. This means he has to drop his desire to be RIGHT. He must forget all about 'being right'. He must be open to dropping his previous ideas that he may have collected over a whole lifetime.
Then - something might just happen, because the disciple is receptive and open. He may 'get it' and one insight leads on to another and soon awakening happens.
An intellectual debate is not the same at all because the essentials are missing.
An example of a Real Dialogue is Krishna and Arjuna. Arjuna questions but only in the spirit of trying to 'get it' and to get clarity. Arjuna is not argumentative - but at the same time he is vocalising his real concerns. When Krishna says "I WAS even before the sun was" - Arjuna is taken aback and questions this.
There is something unique about the dialogue that happens when Guru and disciple meet in this way. This is the real sant mat journey, and history shows that this is what happened to just about every enlightened person - he or she met someone who changed their whole life.
Guru is not a formal title - not a position - like a pope. If it becomes so - then truth has long departed. Guru is also something that cannot be bestowed or passed on. There is nothing to bestow or pass on. It is one's own inner realization.
This is a far cry from what happens in organised religions like sant mat. I call it an organised religion because that is what it is now. The truth has long departed. All that remains is an empty shell. Politics and power plays are in abundance. There are rules and more rules. Satsang is nothing more than a formal gathering. It is the blind leading the blind because often these are conducted by disciples who themsevles have no first-hand experience of the truth.
I was a speaker for quite some time in RSSB and I have seen first hand the ego games that are played by the disciples. Nothing significant happens in RSSB satsang because they are simply giving out theory and telling to you to meditate. In a real satsang - the disciples would get breakthroughs and insights just by being in the satsang. They would begin to awaken and drop their minds.
Recent Comments